If a Florida home appraises below your offer, ask the lender for the report and revised loan figures, then check your signed contract's notice deadlines that day. You may be able to negotiate the price, bring more cash, request an appraisal review or cancel if the contract allows it.
What should you do the day you get a low appraisal?
Get the full report, not just the value, and ask the lender whether the appraisal changes approval, the loan amount or the cash you need. In parallel, locate the appraisal and financing deadlines in your signed papers. Do not wait for the lender to finish a review before checking when notice is due.
- Lender: ask for the loan amount, estimated total payment and revised cash to close at the current price and at a lower price you might negotiate.
- Agent or Florida real estate attorney: identify the applicable clause, exact notice deadline, approved delivery method and who must receive notice.
- Buyer: decide what you can afford without draining savings earmarked for insurance, immediate repairs or emergencies.
How does a low appraisal change the cash you need?
Some purchase loans calculate loan-to-value using the lower of the price or appraised value. If your lender keeps the same loan-to-value percentage but applies it to a lower value, the loan shrinks. The extra cash is the reduction in loan proceeds, not necessarily the full difference between the offer and appraisal.
Say the offer is $350,000 and the lender models 95% financing. If the home had appraised at the offer price, the loan would have been $332,500 and the buyer's share of the purchase price $17,500. At a $335,000 appraisal, 95% is $318,250. If the seller keeps the $350,000 price, the buyer's share rises to $31,750: $14,250 more, even though the price exceeds the appraisal by $15,000.
If the seller instead agrees to $340,000 and the same $318,250 loan still applies, the buyer's share falls to $21,750. These figures isolate the purchase price. They exclude closing costs, prepaids, escrow and any credit for a deposit already paid. The 95% assumption illustrates the arithmetic, not eligibility or a loan offer.
Which Florida contract deadline matters?
The answer depends on what you signed. Florida Realtors distinguishes a separately selected appraisal contingency, which may use a stated value and deadline, from a financing contingency that can turn on whether the lender finds the appraisal sufficient for the loan. A low value alone does not necessarily let you cancel or recover your deposit.
Read the complete signed contract and any riders or amendments. A lender may still be willing to lend after a low valuation, even if you would prefer not to buy at that price. If a deadline is near, work with your agent or Florida real estate attorney to check notice requirements and whether a written extension can be agreed before the deadline.
Separately, under Regulation B, for a mortgage application secured by a first lien on a dwelling, the creditor generally must provide copies of appraisals and other written valuations promptly after completion or no later than three business days before you become contractually obligated on the loan, whichever is earlier. Limited timing waivers can apply. Your right to receive a copy does not extend any separate deadline in your purchase contract.
When is it worth asking for an appraisal review?
If the report has a consequential error or omits relevant evidence, ask the lender about a reconsideration of value. Start with what the appraiser may have missed or misreported, not the number you need. Follow the lender's process, and keep watching the contract clock because the request itself does not extend it.
A useful request identifies the report page, explains why the issue matters and shows support. Examples include documented living area the report appears to have missed or a recent closed sale of a similar home. An asking price alone is not the same as evidence of a closed sale. The lender reviews the request; the appraisal may stay unchanged.
For loans covered by Fannie Mae's rule that require an appraisal report, one borrower-initiated request is allowed per appraisal, with no more than five proposed comparable properties. The borrower cannot submit it after the loan closes. Ask which process applies to your specific loan; do not assume Fannie Mae's rules apply to every lender or program.
How can you decide whether to proceed?
Ask for updated lender numbers before choosing how much more to pay. Compare a price reduction, a smaller increase in your cash contribution and, if permitted, ending the contract. The best choice depends on your available savings, the lender's terms, your willingness to pay above the appraisal and your rights under the signed agreement.
If the seller offers a credit instead of a lower price, ask the lender what it can cover. A credit toward eligible closing costs is not automatically a substitute for a larger buyer contribution. Compare the lender's revised cash-to-close figures side by side, then take account of the cash left over after closing.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to pay the full appraisal gap in cash?
Not automatically. The loan may shrink by less than the price-to-appraisal gap, and a price reduction can lower what you need to bring. The amount depends on the lender's recalculated loan and the final price, plus closing costs and other adjustments.
Does a low appraisal automatically release my earnest money?
No. Deposit rights depend on the signed contract, any riders or amendments, and whether the applicable requirements and notice deadlines were met. A low appraisal, by itself, does not establish who is entitled to the deposit.
Does an appraisal review pause the purchase contract deadline?
No. A lender's appraisal review runs separately from the deadlines in the purchase agreement. A written extension may change a deadline if the parties agree and document it as required, but asking for a review does not itself change the contract.
Official sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: 12 CFR § 1002.14: copies of appraisals and other written valuations (opens in a new tab) Checked
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What a low appraisal means for a buyer (opens in a new tab) Checked
- Florida Realtors: Florida Realtors/Florida Bar financing contingency FAQ (opens in a new tab) Checked
- Fannie Mae: Selling Guide B2-1.2-01: loan-to-value ratios (opens in a new tab) Checked
- Fannie Mae: Selling Guide B4-1.3-12: reconsideration of value (opens in a new tab) Checked
Rates, deadlines, and rules can change after the checked date. Confirm current figures with the official source and your closing agent.

